Concord in Rare and Contested Cases
Concord in rare and contested cases
Concord is the grammatical relationship between a subject and its verb. In complex or unusual sentences, the verb may agree formally with the subject’s head, follow a nearby noun, or reflect the meaning of a collective or coordinated subject. These patterns are useful to recognise when interpreting edited prose and to choose deliberately according to context, register, and dialect.
Formal concord in complex subjects
In formal concord, the verb agrees with the grammatical number and person of the subject’s head noun, not with a noun inside a long modifier or intervening phrase. Identify the head before choosing the verb.
Examples
- The list of proposed amendments, despite several objections, is ready for circulation.
- The reports that the committee commissioned from independent auditors reveal serious weaknesses.
Proximity agreement
Proximity agreement occurs when a verb agrees with the nearest relevant noun rather than with the subject’s grammatical head. It is accepted in some constructions, especially in coordinated subjects with or or nor, but may sound awkward if the nouns differ in number.
Examples
- Neither the interns nor the supervisor is available to answer the call.
- Neither the supervisor nor the interns are available to answer the call.
Notional concord
Notional concord reflects how a subject is understood rather than its singular or plural grammatical form. A collective noun may take a singular verb when treated as one unit, or a plural verb, particularly in British English, when its members are emphasised.
Examples
- The jury has reached a unanimous verdict.
- The jury have returned to their separate rooms.
Agreement with coordinated subjects
With coordinated subjects, agreement depends on the conjunction and intended meaning. Subjects joined by and usually take a plural verb, while or and nor often permit proximity agreement; a singular verb can occur when coordinated expressions denote one person, thing, or concept.
Examples
- The chair and the treasurer are attending the meeting.
- Either the chair or the treasurer is responsible for signing the form.
- Fish and chips is still the most popular dish on the menu.
Choosing among contested alternatives
In contested cases, more than one form may be defensible, but choices vary by dialect, register, and editorial policy. Consider whether the subject is presented as a unit or as individuals, and prefer a clear rephrasing when competing forms could distract or confuse.
Examples
- A number of researchers are questioning the initial findings.
- The number of researchers questioning the initial findings is growing.
- The committee has issued its recommendation.
Try it
The quality of the recordings, rather than the microphones, ___ the final result.
Practise Concord in Rare and Contested Cases with exercises
Sign up for free to get exercises for every part of this topic and track your progress.
Sign up and practise